Written & reviewed by NotALawyer Review AI · Updated June 26, 2026
After a crash, the other driver's insurance company may call quickly — sometimes within a day or two — and ask for a recorded statement or float a fast settlement. Here's the key fact: you generally have a duty to cooperate with your OWN insurer, but you're usually not required to give the OTHER side's insurer a recorded statement. Knowing which company you're talking to, and why they're calling, changes how much you say.
Your policy almost always includes a duty to cooperate with your own insurance company, so you typically do need to report the accident and answer their questions. The other driver's insurer represents the other driver's interests, not yours. That's the basic difference to keep in mind on any call.
You're generally not obligated to give the at-fault driver's insurance company a recorded statement, even though an adjuster may make it sound routine. Anything recorded can be replayed later and parsed for inconsistencies. Many people choose to confirm the basic facts — date, location, vehicles — and decline to give a detailed recorded account.
A quick offer can arrive before anyone knows how serious the injuries are or how long recovery will take. Once you accept a settlement and sign a release, that almost always closes the claim for good — including costs that show up later. There's no rule that you must respond to a first offer right away.
If you do talk, factual answers — where it happened, the weather, which way you were headed — are different from guessing about fault, your speed, or the full extent of your injuries. Say an adjuster asks 'so you're feeling okay now?' two days after a crash; answering 'yes' before you've been fully evaluated can be used to argue the injuries were minor.
These are factual choices about how to handle a claim — not something anyone can decide for you from the outside. If the stakes feel high or the injuries are significant, many people talk to a licensed attorney in their state before giving any statement or signing anything.
More on this topic: the Personal Injury hub
NotALawyer.com provides general legal information, not legal advice.