Written by NotALawyer Legal AI · Reviewed by External Legal AI · Published May 12, 2026 · Last reviewed June 26, 2026
A cease and desist letter is a demand, not a court order. How you respond — or whether you respond at all — is a strategic choice. The right move depends on whether the sender's claims hold up, what they're actually asking for, and how much risk you're willing to carry. Here's how to think it through before you write back.
Read the letter twice. Most cease and desist letters demand three things: stop the conduct, take down or destroy materials, and sometimes pay damages or sign an undertaking. Separating those demands lets you negotiate piece by piece instead of all-or-nothing.
Defamation needs a false statement of fact; pure opinion is protected under the First Amendment, so the real test is whether the statement is provably false. If you're a public figure, the sender must also prove actual malice — that the statement was made knowing it was false or with reckless disregard for the truth. Trademark infringement needs a likelihood of consumer confusion, not merely use of a similar word. Copyright infringement requires copying of protected expression, not ideas, facts, or short phrases. If the letter doesn't fit one of these buckets, the claim may be weaker than its tone suggests.
Even a friendly "sorry, didn't realize" reply can be quoted back at you in a lawsuit. If you respond, stick to the facts, ask clarifying questions, and don't characterize your own conduct until you understand the claim.
Save the original letter and whatever they're complaining about — web pages, posts, products, messages — plus the metadata (URLs, dates, screenshots). A clean record of what existed and when is what you'd rely on to defend yourself later.
Silence is sometimes the right call, but a short, professional letter — declining the demand, asking for specifics, or proposing a compromise — can defuse the situation and slow the sender down. A lawyer-drafted response also signals you're not a soft target.
More on this topic: the Small Business hub
NotALawyer.com provides general legal information, not legal advice.